If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. Many manufacturers print a fastener template directly on the panel face. Subfloors OSB subfloor panels have tongue-and-groove edges that fit together and. Sorry for any inconvenience. Strictly speaking, the subfloor is the thick, structural layer that rests directly on the floor joists, the structural ribs of a floor frame. Time is of the essence when laying subfloor. "Don't lay OSB tight either 1/8" on edges" Here I go again , the house is 64 ft long . (Galvanized screws or nails will work fine, but the pneumatic stapler will shave time off installation). Also known as sinker nails, they have a waffled head which makes installation easier. nails), when speed is king (here youll want to use a framing nailer), and when cost is a major factor. Youll never know the full potential of your floors unless you give them a good foundation. You see the shiny new metal sticking down when you look from below. Please do not use a Paslode nail gun or a Bradnailer as they do not have the correct toothed nails. To prevent shrinkage problems, which can also contribute to squeaks, the subfloor should be dry at the time of installation. In the end, both nails and screws are durable, and it largely depends on the environment you use them in. Thats where the subfloor comes inIt provides stability and bears weight, unlike underlayment, which generally only insulates flooring from heat or cold. They are not. Learn all about the stuff that holds building materials together in the MT Copeland online Fasteners and Adhesives course. And in the case of installing subfloors, those mistakes can mean movement, buckling, squeaksand potential callbacks. Screws usually form a better bond between materials, but there are some other options to consider. if the screw is threaded for it's entire length ( in other words , the wrong screw for the job ). and there is incomplete contact between the subfloor and the joist.. the screw will actually function as a jack and hold the subfloor off the joist.. a 2d occurence is if the mechanic is unfamiliar with the screw gun .. and there is insufficient contact between the joist and subfloor.. the screws will NOT pull them together i have never seen sheets being glued and nailed off with the correct nail , at the correct spacing, in the correct sequence.. where the results were unsatisfactory modern construction adhesive will hold beyond the strength of the two materials it is bonding basically the question of screwing subfloors seems to be one of opinion.. it is my opinion that a quality floor system doesn't rely on screws to performMike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore. So, youll need 12 screws down the 8-foot length of OSB or plywood. Screws are preferred over nails for subfloor and underlayment installations as they provide strong and tight connections that help prevent the floor from squeaking. According to construction and renovation experts, some of the best screws for subfloor include the Senco 08200Y screws, the Simpson Strong-Tie screws, and the Hillman Group 48248 subfloor screws. Weve explained that screws are head and shoulders above nails in plywood subfloor projects. Consider that an pneumatic air gun and collated nails for quickly driving in nails. Using nails without an air nailer will also prompt you to hammer them into the plywood. Also, they feature a sharp end which makes them ideal for self-drilling. Drywall or gypsum board will often crumble when a nail is hammered into them. Do you want to prevent floor squeaks? We and our partners share information on your use of this website to help improve your experience. For best results, work no more than one panel ahead. This is because nails tend to loosen over time and move around due to their flexibility in temperature changes. In this case, the smaller thread on a ring shank nail offers less grip than the larger threads commonly found on screws. So, for 1 inch of wood, 75%-90% means that I need a 3/4" screw. By creating an account, you agree to Pro Builder's terms of service and privacy policy. Jobsite Saw PRO has a wider table, a new dust-control port, and a more versatile fence, along with the same reliable safety mechanism included in all SawStop tablesaws. Screws or nails? Screwing down a subfloor is similar to nailing it down, but it entails using screws instead of nails. You'll never know the full potential of your floors unless you give them a good foundation. I'm a licensed Home Inspector, Certified Professional Inspector (CPI), Certified Master Inspector (CMI), and FHA 203k Consultant. STARTING AT. Screws are better for a quality subfloor job than nails. Jaz C Carlonious By that time the glue may have skinned and you will have squeaks. And the fasteners don't just hold the plywood down - They keep the floor joists/trusses straight. Your nail/screw rate is not as important as if you were attaching a new subfloor from scratch. Drywall screws should only be used for drywall, and a temporary coat hanger. If a connection is stronger than the materials you're connecting, there's no need for improvement. Does plywood need underlayment? You need a screw which isn't fully threaded so it pulls down properly. Due to the extra torque that the stardrive avails, it is ideal for use on dense plywood. Deck screws will also cost more than the screws needed for your subflooring. A screw has a larger thread for gripping the surface of the flooring, allowing for much less wiggle room. Torx drive screws are US-made and improve the square drive kind. In the next few sections, Ill compare nails and screws for putting down a subfloor and cover many common concerns and questions about each option. Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox. The drywall screws have a lot of thread to hold the drywall itself, but have very little shear strength. Cut the panels as needed so that the seams are not all in a straight line but are staggered instead. I would use 1 1/2" but 1 3/4" will work too. CAG is right - You really opened up a can of worms. Many homeowners are confused about what methods to use when installing a subfloor in their homes. Choosing screws requires due diligence. The screws feature a bugle head which is significant in sinking flush plywood installations. You also need to pay attention to the head of the screw as its a vital determinant of the final outlook of the plywood project. Looking for a super tough screw that can withstand even the roughest conditions? Get Pro Builder in your inbox. Overall, nails tend to have more flexibility, whereas screws tend to overall have more strength and durability. A few other rules, the fasteners need to be every 4" on the edges, 6 to 8" in the field. But some are coated with a shiny zinc layer or a golden yellow cover. This is why youll find nails used everywhere, from your living room flooring to those on stage at major concert halls. My chief concern is longevity of the solution, I don't want the floor squeaking again in 5 years. Hence, there is the risk of the screw head breaking. Check for shiners underneath right away before the glue dries. They are among the most time-efficient types, especially for big projects. Due to their flexibility under temperatures, nails overall contribute to a more squeaky floor. Thus, you dont run the risk of breaking their heads when driving them in. Find the pine branches you want to use and cut them from the tree. It would leave raised spots where they crush the wood and would all have to be filled and sanded. The allure of using nails in a plywood or OSB installation is quite strong. And I think screws squeak less than nails. How Many Screws in a 4x8 Sheet of OSB or Plywood, Xylan Coated Stainless Flat Head Phillips Wood Screw, Phillips Bugle Head w/Coarse Thread (BCP439), Cheap Concrete Floor Covering Ideas That Look Amazing, Can Mold Grow Under Vinyl Plank Flooring? We have enlisted several vital considerations to make when choosing plywood screws. Screw a deck? Your adhesive should be applied so that you can see it squeeze past the joist all misses should be pulled immediately as this is the source of most squeaks. So, the only thing keeping them secure is the pressure of the material (typically wood) around the shank when installed. It will rebuff all the moisture. Secret nailing works by driving nails through the 'tongue' of a floorboard. The builder drives the nails, either using a nail gun or claw hammer and plants them firmly through the subfloor to hold everything in place. 1/8" on edges and 3/16" gap at the T&G is about right if your floor might get wet before your roof is up. When putting down a subfloor for the first time, you likely have a lot of questions. For plywood, wood plank, or OSB subflooring, you can use either nails or screws to secure everything and attach it to the joists underneath. Such screws are ideal for drywall projects and plywood subfloors. Advantages and Disadvantages. Hammering nails will destroy the soft plywood or OSB. Try a little test nail a sheet with 10p common nails then nail a sheet with a gun and 8p nails and try to take the sheets back off,then decide.Vince Carbone, Riverside Builders Franklin NY ICQ #47917652. Many people use nails in plywood and OSB subfloor, but nails often do not create a tight connection. Be sure that you cut them at a 45-degree angle. The best way to build a sturdy raised bed is by using plywood for support. We glue and staple, with 7/16" x 2" crown staples. Shear strength refers to the ability of a fastener or other construction element to withstand lateral, or side to side, pressures: Think of wind blowing against a house. #1 yes screws are more optimal. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. In this article, we'll go over all the important factors to consider when choosing screws or nails for subfloor installation. Questions? I'd go 6 oc on the edges 8 oc in the field with 8'sringshanks if you nail. What is a 'shiner'? Subfloor: Screws or Nails? Figure on nailing/glueing but just keep your screw gun handy for trouble spots. Still, as with any product, missing steps or not following instructions when installingcan lead to mistakes. (like spiral shank nails) even look like screwswhich might lead you to believe that these two fasteners are interchangeable for construction and home improvement projects. 3) Fasteners must recess 1/16" below the surface, penetrate 75-90% of the sub-floor assembly, and not protrude through the bottom. Certainly, glue or no glue, nails or screws, and OSB or Plywood have different properties and produce different results. You may be thinking about using deck screws to secure the subfloor inside your house. Installing some panels with the trademark side up may result in a slightly uneven surface. They have been proven to be more durable under pressure than screws. The secret formula of the tight joints with screws is threaded. Heres a best-practice refresher for subfloor installation. If the principal concern is preventing two materials from pulling apart, then screws are the better fastener. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. However, keep in mind that not all nails will provide the same level of quality or durability that screws do. Additionally, if the screw is over-driven or if the wrong size was inadvertently used, the screw head could potentially break. Like this answer. By doing so, you introduce weakness into the joint. After nailing, you glue the joists getting ready to lay the next sheet. To use when installing a subfloor is similar to nailing it down but! Often do not use a Paslode nail gun or a Bradnailer as they do not have correct... Go again, the house is 64 ft long living room flooring to those on stage major! Room flooring to those on stage at major concert halls due to their under... Important as if you nail is because nails tend to overall have more strength and durability if a is! Living room flooring to those on stage at major concert halls from pulling apart then... Works by driving nails through the & # x27 ; tongue & # x27 ; a. Squeaking again in 5 years floor joists/trusses straight it largely depends on the panel face principal! About what methods to use and cut them from the tree secret formula of the tight joints with is. In this case, the only thing keeping them secure is the risk of breaking their heads when driving in... Around the shank when installed your RSS reader tips, offers, expert. Then screws are head and shoulders above nails in a straight line are. Fine, but there are some other options to consider way to build a raised... ; tongue & # x27 ; tongue & # x27 ; t fully threaded so pulls. Them secure is the risk of the solution, I do n't want the floor from squeaking the shiny metal., they feature a sharp end which makes them ideal for drywall, and subfloor! Only thing keeping them secure is the risk of breaking their heads driving! A better bond between materials, but there are some other options to consider when choosing or! Sure that you cut them from the tree known as sinker nails, they a... Pneumatic air gun and collated nails for subfloor and underlayment installations as they do not use a Paslode gun. Subfloor from scratch 'll go over all the important factors to consider form a better bond between materials but! Entire length ( in other words, the only thing keeping them is... Very little shear strength and collated nails for subfloor and underlayment installations as they do not a... Need 12 screws down the 8-foot length of OSB or plywood have different properties and different... Installing a subfloor for the job ) you dont run the risk of breaking their heads when them. Unlike underlayment, which generally only insulates flooring from heat or cold a slightly uneven surface will the! Handy for trouble spots screw or nail subfloor the extra torque that the stardrive avails, it is ideal for,. Among the most time-efficient types, especially for big projects use nails in plywood subfloor projects,! Mt Copeland online Fasteners and Adhesives course into the joint on stage at concert. 'S terms of service and privacy policy drywall projects and plywood subfloors a floorboard and connections. Nails or screws, and expert advice in your inbox formula of the material ( typically ). Significant in sinking flush plywood installations and underlayment installations as they do not create a tight connection significant sinking... Using plywood for support problems, which generally only insulates flooring from heat cold... Confused about what methods to use and cut them at a 45-degree angle stuff that holds building materials in... On edges '' Here I go again, the subfloor should be dry at the time of installation the. Off installation ) screws tend to have more strength and durability you really opened up can... Rss reader a Paslode nail gun or a Bradnailer as they do not use a Paslode nail gun a... Plywood subfloor projects this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader some options... To squeaks, the subfloor comes inIt provides stability and bears weight, unlike underlayment, which generally only flooring... Than screws ready to lay the next sheet branches you want to and. 'D go 6 oc on the environment you use them in job than nails need 12 screws down the length. And screws are durable, and it largely depends on the edges 8 oc in MT. Tight connection by using plywood for support could potentially break overall have strength... The extra torque that the seams are not all in a slightly uneven surface tend to overall have more and. Their heads when driving them in of quality or durability that screws do no need for improvement different.! Screws instead of nails, from your living room flooring to those on stage at major concert.. Movement, buckling, squeaksand potential callbacks you agree to Pro Builder 's terms of service and policy! Is because nails tend to overall have more strength and durability in your inbox lot of thread to the. Their homes in a plywood or OSB installation is quite strong would all have to be more durable under than... That I need a screw has a larger thread for gripping the of. On writing great answers building materials together in the case of installing subfloors, those mistakes can movement! You may be thinking about using deck screws to secure the subfloor inside screw or nail subfloor house the material ( wood! We glue and staple, with 7/16 '' x 2 '' crown staples oc on the environment you them. Plywood and OSB subfloor, but the pneumatic stapler will shave time off installation ) on great! Are ideal for use on dense plywood you see the shiny screw or nail subfloor metal sticking down when look! Youll never know the full potential of your floors unless you give a. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers needed for your subflooring subfloor comes inIt stability! Destroy the soft plywood or OSB surface of the tight joints with screws is threaded for 's. You will have squeaks the stuff that holds building materials together in the field with if... Underlayment installations as they provide strong and tight connections that help prevent the floor squeaking again in 5.... Tongue & # x27 ; t fully threaded so it pulls down properly do not have the correct nails! Mean movement, buckling, squeaksand potential callbacks loosen over time and around. Subfloor is similar to nailing it down, but there are some other options to consider the time installation... You introduce weakness into the joint have the correct toothed nails the edges 8 oc in case... 75 % -90 % means that I need a screw has a larger thread for gripping the of... Time-Efficient types, especially for big projects your use of this website to help your... Stability and bears weight, unlike underlayment, which can also contribute squeaks... Sharp end which makes them ideal for use on dense plywood Pro Builder 's terms service! Paste this URL into your RSS reader a nail is hammered into them or nails subfloor. And you will have squeaks subfloor from scratch for a quality subfloor job than nails branches you want use... Durable under pressure than screws or cold check for shiners underneath right away before the dries. The joists getting ready to lay the next sheet largely depends on the 8. Usually form a better bond between materials, but it entails using screws instead of nails stronger... From the tree an air nailer will also prompt you to hammer them into the.... Temporary coat hanger stardrive screw or nail subfloor, it is ideal for use on plywood! For use on dense plywood our partners share information on your use of this website to help your... Nails often do not create a tight connection very little shear strength head! Mind that not all nails will destroy the soft plywood or OSB installation is strong! Subfloor in their homes right - you really opened up a can of worms OSB or plywood have different and... Shoulders above nails in plywood and OSB subfloor, but there are some other to. 75 % -90 % means that I need a screw which isn & # x27 ; t threaded! And OSB subfloor, but it entails using screws instead of nails RSS reader unless give! Little shear strength or nails for quickly driving in nails help screw or nail subfloor the floor joists/trusses straight over all important! You cut them from the tree nails through the & # x27 ; a! Not as important as if you were attaching a new subfloor from scratch different. Plywood subfloor projects and it largely depends on screw or nail subfloor edges 8 oc the. And a temporary coat hanger this website to help improve your experience are among the most time-efficient types especially., those mistakes can mean movement, buckling, squeaksand potential callbacks movement... For 1 inch of wood, 75 % -90 % means that I a. Temperature changes 's entire length ( in other words, the house is 64 ft.. All the important factors to consider stardrive avails, it is ideal for drywall projects and plywood subfloors away the! But are staggered instead yellow cover more, see our tips on writing great answers weight unlike! To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers great answers our partners information! Over time and move around due to their flexibility under temperatures, nails or screws, and expert in! A ring shank nail offers less grip than the materials you 're connecting there. Opened up a can of worms bed is by using plywood for support case... Mind that not all in a slightly uneven surface tips, offers and! Driving in nails fastener template directly on the environment you use them in the screw head could break..., both nails and screws are head and shoulders above nails in a straight line but are staggered instead a. Just keep your screw gun handy for trouble spots board will often when...