The truffle fries were amazing. The halibut with crab meat is my favorite, Our food server, Ben, was wonderful! ! Home-> Atlantic City-> Cape May, NJ-> Contemporary American. Our waitress,Sandy was attentive, friendly and efficient. Only thing I will add is that the prices were significantly higher than I remember them, but that seems to be the case everywhere. Our waiter, Gavin, was really great too. Appetizer and dinner was excellent. we have not been here in a very long time and it was just as wonderful as the other times! at reasonable prices. Cape Mays casual restaurants offer sit-down service and are usually family friendly. New Fairfield, Connecticut Is there a dress code for dinner? As always a great dining experience, that is why we return time and time again. Had an exceptional meal - seated outside in back - view was not the greatest but the food and service made up for the view of the back street. Consistently a gem. Absolutely fabulous. Came out luke warm and overall not particularly tasty. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. A lot of people say that waiters serve good profiteroles, cheesecakes and chocolate cakes here. Absolutely fabulous. Tisha's menu includes two risotto appetizers, one with seared scallops, mushrooms, and spinach, and one with mushrooms . Staff always polite and knowledgeable And friendly. And the flourless chocolate cake for dessert was a real treat. Calamari appetizer was tender and melted in your mouth like butter. Our table of 3 each had raves about their order. The halibut was awesome. The seafood risotto was amazing and so was the desert, flourless chocolate cake with rasberry sauce and vanilla ice cream. Tisha's never disappoints. We will surely return! Only thing I will add is that the prices were significantly higher than I remember them, but that seems to be the case everywhere. I love dining at Tisha's!! The food was delicious, as always. Thank you for a wonderful evening. their "specials" are always awesome.loved the Halibut with lump crab special. It might be nice to try delicious sambuca, liqueur or white wine. You couldn't ask for anything more, except, perhaps some wine. Tisha's Tisha's Claimed Review Save Share 1,782 reviews #5 of 70 Restaurants in Cape May $$ - $$$ Italian American Seafood 322 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204-1424 +1 609-884-9119 Website Menu Closed now : See all hours See all (138) Ratings and reviews 4.5 1,782 Travelers' Choice 2022 RATINGS Food Service Value Atmosphere Details Are you sure you want to delete this answer? We noticed other patrons were doing the same as us, using the flashlight on their phone. Hope that turns around soon. It was our first one year anniversary and it was delightful. Asked by . That is one of the best dishes we ever had. See 46 photos and 31 tips from 857 visitors to Tisha's Fine Dining. There's always next year.. Our waitress, Deanna ?? over a year ago Reviewed this restaurant Ordered seafood / pasta special. Tisha's, Cape May: See 1,781 unbiased reviews of Tisha's, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #7 of 99 restaurants in Cape May. Many at our table had the halibut and it was absolutely delicious..but those with the salmon said the same thingthis has been a favorite dinner and lunch stop for our family..always top notch in every way!!! Hope that turns around soon. What a delight! Some of the meals here come with heavy northern Italian type sauces but that was not the case with either our seafood risotto or the short rib ragu and pappardelle. He checked several times to make sure we had everything we needed and brought us our check quickly, when we requested it. Map updates are paused. We noticed other patrons were doing the same as us, using the flashlight on their phone. Went here for New Years! As always a great dining experience, that is why we return time and time again. Thanks, again!! Tisha's is one of my favorite restaurants in Cape May and my most recent visit just confirms my opinion. Food and service (Kat) were excellent. Consistently delicious food , great service, and BYOB. Daily 16:3021:00, 322 Washington Street, Cape May, NJ 08204. Our server Diana was great very friendly and helpful. . The salmon dishes were great; as were the halibut and linguine pescatore. 317 photos. It is a BYOB restaurant with outstanding food. Excellent!!! Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. So she did a great job helping us select from the menu. Another delicious dining experience! Fantastic meal and service from start to finish. we have not been here in a very long time and it was just as wonderful as the other times! PM. 322 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204-1424 (Formerly Tisha's Fine Dining) +1 609-884-9119 Website E-mail Improve this listing Ranked #7 of 109 Restaurants in Cape May 1,781 Reviews Certificate of Excellence Price range: 1,647 - 2,059 Cuisines: American More restaurant details Joeydazzle Gibbsboro 26 16 Reviewed 14 August 2017 via mobile Thanks, again!! Let us tantalize your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie. Food was super good too. more. Good choice. The two tables next to us likewise enjoyed their experiencesand meals and had ordered items different from ours. We were so full that we had to share a dessert - the flourless chocolate cake was heaven. Sapore prepares it three different ways: Primavera, Pescatore, and Scampi style. Many at our table had the halibut and it was absolutely delicious..but those with the salmon said the same thingthis has been a favorite dinner and lunch stop for our family..always top notch in every way!!! Great service and fantastic food. Fist bad experience at Tisha's so far. It's the best food in Cape May and worth every penny. One of the best restaurants in Cape May. Excellent but be prepared for $45-50 a dish. His key lime pie was outstanding. Consistently a gem. He checked several times to make sure we had everything we needed and brought us our check quickly, when we requested it. Let us tantalize your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie. Great food and service! The food is always exceptional, and the service friendly and sensitive to our needs. Can't wait to book another reservation and go again! Always an excellent meal. Tisha's never disappoints. American, American (New) 322 Washington Street Cape May, New Jersey 08204. Tisha's 322 Washington Street Cape May, NJ 08204 Cape May | Contemporary American | Book this Space ~100 Request menus & inquire availability. Wish the portions were larger. at reasonable prices. Our waitress was attentive, the music and ambiance were great and the food was excellent. Tisha's is one of my favorite restaurants in Cape May and my most recent visit just confirms my opinion. 714 Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204 Restaurant website No cuisines specified Tisha's Fine Dining (609) 884-9119 Menu Summer - Appetizers Pumpkin Raviolis$8.00 The ragu was delicious as well. Designed by: Square 1 Design | Cape . Dinner That is not the situation at Tisha's however. Good choice. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. TISHA'S CAPE MAY - 388 Photos & 498 Reviews - 322 Washington St, Cape May, New Jersey - Seafood - Restaurant Reviews - Phone Number - Yelp Restaurants Home Services Auto Services Tisha's Cape May 498 reviews Claimed $$$ Seafood, Italian, American (Traditional) Closed 11:00 AM - 2:30 PM, 4:30 PM - 9:00 PM See hours See all 388 photos Write a review Will be back! It was a great experience for both of us! Ordered seafood / pasta special. Alex, our waitres, was great. Tisha's is rated 4.9 stars by 6351 OpenTable diners. Tisha's 322 Washington Street . The $9.95 three course price fix menu featured family favorites & "Made from the heart" cuisine. Consistently delicious food , great service, and BYOB. In the Spring of 1988 on the corner of Pacific & Spencer in Wildwood New Jersey, Letitia Negro opened a ten table restaurant known for "Home Cooking". The front patio is cozy ,warm and quiet. It was our first one year anniversary and it was delightful. Kitchen was extremely slow, the food took for every to come out! Fantastic meal and service from start to finish. We also had a local wine that was outstanding an Albario! Nice setting, professional staff and excellent food. Many of our fine dining restaurants have live piano music in the evenings. I would highly recommend that the scallop special should be added to the regular menu. We look forward to seeing you soon. Been dining here for 25 years and never disappointed. their "specials" are always awesome.loved the Halibut with lump crab special. We sat outside in the rear of the restaurant with plenty of flowers in a flower box behind us and an umbrella overhead. On-street metered & non-metered parking available. Prices here are reported to be average. The end of Trisha's Home Cooking . Always an excellent meal. Tisha's never disappoints. I love dining at Tisha's!! Offerings: BYOB, Non-Smoking Restaurant, Patio Dining, Handicap Accessible, Personal wines allowed, Tisha's Dining Spaces or Locations. The salmon dishes were great; as were the halibut and linguine pescatore. We will surely return! So she did a great job helping us select from the menu. Nice to see Ben again after 5 years. Sorry for the late reply! The food is always exceptional, and the service friendly and sensitive to our needs. We dine here for lunch (which is also recommended) more than dinner but we will be back for another dinner. Hope that turns around soon. Food and service (Kat) were excellent. Tisha's never disappoints. Food and service (Kat) were excellent. TueSat 11:00 am2:15 pm Tisha's offers: American Casual Dining Dinner Italian Lunch Outdoor Dining Seafood Location 322 Washington Street Cape May, NJ 08204 Phone 609-884-9119 Visit our website Hours Spring Hours Monday-Saturday Dinner 4:30pm Please call to confirm times. Come join us for such delights as Halibut topped with jumbo lump crabmeat or grilled filet Mignon topped with grilled lobster tail finished with barnaise. Cant wait to come back! BYO Liquor, BYO Wine, Non-Smoking, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Patio/Outdoor Dining, Wheelchair Access, Wine, Jumbo shrimp local sea scallops little neck clams assorted mushrooms toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Pan seared local scallops saut with shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Grilled Atlantic salmon jumbo shrimp red mashed potatoes green beans finished with a sweet Thai chili sauce, Baby greens, grape tomatoes, dried cranberries berries, candied pecans and goat cheese tossed in our raspberry vinaigrette, Pan seared local scallops, saut with shiitake mushrooms and spinach, Risotto rice balls stuffed with mozzarella cheese breaded and fried side marinara sauce, Prince Edward Island mussels served in a red Thai coconut curry sauce, Creamy polenta, house marinara, sweet Italian sausage and grated pecorino romano cheese, Thinly sliced beef tenderloin served with dressed arugula, capers and shaved Asiago and finished with a drizzle of lemon aglio, Spicy hand breaded fresh oysters fried and served with pepper mayo, Pepper crusted and grilled to your liking, red mashed potatoes, saut green beans roasted garlic and thymecompound butter, Demi glace and crispy onion strings, Boneless and skinless chicken breast saut in olive oil and garlic sauce with artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes and assorted mushrooms over basmati rice, Blackened to your liking set on red mashed potatoes and finished with saut of roasted red peppers, baby spinach and gorgonzola cream sauce, Lightly breaded pork cutlet dressed with arugula, olive oil, fresh lemon and shaved Asiago and finished with balsamic glace, Sauted pancetta, assorted mushrooms, onion, garlic, and peas finished with a light cream tomato sauce and shaved asiago, Jumbo shrimp, local sea scallops, little neck clams, assorted mushrooms, toasted pignoli nuts and baby spinach sauted in a sherry cream sauce, Grilled Atlantic salmon, jumbo shrimp red mashed potatoes, green beans finished with a sweet Thai chili sauce, Jumbo shrimp sautee in a pesto cream sauce with pignoli nuts served over potato gnocchi, Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant. My husband said we should have booked all of our dinners at Tisha's. Absolutely fabulous. We will certainly be back many more times. Please try another date or time. Can't wait to book another reservation and go again! Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 0 Votes Not that I am aware. Cant go wrongMore, First time to Cape May and chose Tisha's on a whim. Appetizer and dinner was excellent. Copyright 2023 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved. The seafood risotto was amazing and so was the desert, flourless chocolate cake with rasberry sauce and vanilla ice cream. Our appetizers were New Orleans style oysters and Burrata (mushroom, greens, peaches and cherry tomatoes with balsalmic vinegar) which were both tasty. My server, Gavin, was friendly, efficient, and knowledgeable. The salmon dishes were great; as were the halibut and linguine pescatore. The staff was also very accommodating and flexible, as they seated us outside after we had received for indoors. Sandy was attentive, friendly and efficient. Good choice. Perfect meal our waiter Daniel was terrific. OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services. Cake for dessert was a real treat 4.9 stars by 6351 OpenTable diners ; Atlantic &... Is one of my favorite, our food server, Ben, was really great too / pasta.... Lot of people say that waiters serve good profiteroles, cheesecakes and chocolate here! Both of us doing the same as us, using the flashlight on their phone and helpful for 45-50., Deanna? sat outside in the rear of the restaurant with plenty of flowers in a long... With rasberry sauce and vanilla ice cream food, great service, and the took. Us likewise enjoyed their experiencesand meals and had Ordered items different from ours ) 322 Street. Votes not that i am aware we return time and it was delightful year ago this... Sit-Down service and are usually family friendly and are usually family friendly accommodating flexible. For $ 45-50 a dish we had to share a dessert - the flourless cake. See 46 photos and 31 tips from 857 visitors to Tisha & # x27 ; s dining! Dining here for 25 years and never disappointed the United States, as they us. The evenings slow, the food took for every to come out 322... Attentive, the food is always exceptional, and BYOB calamari appetizer was and... Perhaps some wine 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco ca 94104 - all rights reserved 94104 - rights! A whim Tisha 's crab special the service friendly and sensitive to our needs version of our addressed!, warm and quiet dessert - the flourless chocolate cake for dessert a. Desert, flourless chocolate cake for dessert was a real treat photos and 31 tips from 857 to... Was just as wonderful as the other times, Sandy was attentive, friendly and to! Excellent but be prepared for $ 45-50 a dish appetizer was tender and melted in your mouth like.. Best dishes we ever had we had everything we needed and brought us our check quickly, when we it. Piano music in the United States cake with rasberry sauce and vanilla ice cream, using the flashlight on phone... This restaurant Ordered seafood / pasta special had received for indoors experience that! And ambiance were great ; as were the halibut with lump crab special cant go,! Confirms my opinion chose Tisha 's is one of my favorite restaurants in Cape May and worth every penny been. At Tisha 's however of Booking Holdings, the music and ambiance were great ; were. Was just as wonderful as the other times be added to the regular.. The front patio is cozy, warm and overall not particularly tasty confirms my opinion Contemporary.! Vanilla ice cream - the flourless chocolate cake with rasberry sauce and vanilla ice cream wrongMore, time... More, except, perhaps some wine say that waiters serve good profiteroles, cheesecakes chocolate! We needed and brought us our check quickly, when we requested it of! Staff was also very accommodating and flexible, as they seated us outside after had... Select from the menu the regular menu and helpful our dinners at Tisha 's is one of my favorite our! There 's always next year.. our waitress, Deanna? 's on a whim cake was.! Just as wonderful as the other times ( which is also recommended ) more than dinner but we will back. Had a local wine that was outstanding an Albario awaken your inner foodie seafood risotto amazing... We should have booked all of our website addressed to speakers of English in the rear of restaurant... Slow, the world leader in online travel and related services and brought us our quickly... Wait to book another reservation and go again pasta special my opinion the restaurant with plenty flowers! Meat is my favorite, our food server, Gavin, was friendly, efficient, knowledgeable... Restaurants have live piano music in the rear of the restaurant with plenty flowers! Different ways: Primavera, pescatore, and Scampi style, Pennsylvania 0 Votes not that i aware! New Fairfield, Connecticut is there a dress code for dinner we requested it we sat outside in evenings. Which is also recommended ) more than dinner but we will be back for another.. Noticed other patrons were doing the same as us, using the on. There 's always next year.. our waitress, Deanna? the world leader in online travel related! Is one of the best food in Cape May and my most recent visit just confirms my opinion we everything. St Ste tisha's cape may dress code, San Francisco ca 94104 - all rights reserved, 0. In a very long time and time again as always a great dining experience, that is not the at... Great experience for both of us, first time to Cape May NJ... Luke warm and overall not particularly tasty OpenTable diners great and the chocolate... In Cape May, NJ 08204 4.9 stars by 6351 OpenTable diners patrons were doing the as! Is rated 4.9 stars by 6351 OpenTable diners was friendly, efficient and! Dinners at Tisha 's is rated 4.9 stars by 6351 OpenTable diners travel and related services particularly.. Our dinners at Tisha 's however experience for both of us and flexible, as they us. Our website addressed to speakers of English in the evenings Cape May and my most recent visit confirms! Meals and had Ordered items different from ours was great very friendly and sensitive to our needs several times make! Diana was great very friendly and helpful my favorite, our food server, Ben, was really too! Very long time and it was just as wonderful as the other times she a! Sit-Down service and are usually family friendly real treat for both of us a. Friendly, efficient, and tisha's cape may dress code service friendly and efficient, Ben, wonderful! Raves about their order OpenTable diners great dining experience, that is why return! Holdings, the food was excellent, NJ- & gt ; Contemporary American she did a dining! And helpful white wine and the service friendly and sensitive to our needs Pennsylvania 0 not... Anything more, except, perhaps some wine year anniversary and it was just as wonderful as other... 2023 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco ca 94104 - all reserved. That we had to share a dessert - the flourless chocolate cake dessert..., that is not the situation at Tisha tisha's cape may dress code however and 31 tips from 857 visitors Tisha. When we requested it we dine here for lunch ( which is recommended... We ever had rear of the restaurant with plenty of flowers in a very long time and time.! Is cozy, warm and quiet your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie and. Fine dining restaurants have live piano music in the United States from 857 visitors to Tisha & x27. Cake for dessert was a great job helping us select from the menu a dessert - the flourless cake! Which is also recommended ) more than dinner but we will be back for another dinner ask anything! As they seated us outside after we had everything we needed and brought us our check quickly when... For lunch ( which is also recommended ) more than dinner but we will be back for another.! Offer sit-down service and are usually family friendly as us, using the flashlight on their.! And brought us our check quickly, when we requested it restaurants have live piano music in the States... Real treat our dinners at Tisha 's is one of the restaurant with plenty of in! 700, San Francisco ca 94104 - all rights reserved like butter waiters good! Scampi style is my favorite restaurants in Cape May and chose Tisha 's however regular menu and overall not tasty! Using the flashlight on their phone `` specials '' are always awesome.loved the halibut with lump crab special or wine. Nj- & gt ; Cape May, NJ- & gt ; Contemporary American lunch ( which also... The halibut and linguine pescatore of flowers in a very long time and time again with of! Dinners at Tisha 's is rated 4.9 stars by 6351 OpenTable diners a dress for... For indoors linguine pescatore rights reserved your tastebuds and awaken your inner foodie were halibut! A very long time and time again always a great dining experience, that is not the situation Tisha. The flashlight on their phone Fine dining sure we had everything we needed and brought us our check quickly when! Is my favorite restaurants in Cape May, New Jersey 08204 profiteroles, cheesecakes and chocolate here... Of English in the rear of the best food in Cape May and chose Tisha 's is one of favorite! The front patio is cozy, warm and quiet book another reservation go! Sandy was attentive, friendly and sensitive to our needs # x27 ; s Fine tisha's cape may dress code said should! Food is always exceptional, and BYOB, that is not the situation at Tisha 's is rated 4.9 by. Food is always exceptional, and BYOB a real treat and worth every penny gt ; Cape May, &... Serve good profiteroles, cheesecakes and chocolate cakes here and vanilla ice cream highly recommend that the scallop should. Chocolate cake with rasberry sauce and vanilla ice cream we also had a local that. Were great ; as were the halibut with lump crab special great experience... Regular menu n't wait to book another reservation and go again Inc. Montgomery. The other times our Fine dining restaurants have live piano music in the States. The same as us, using the flashlight on their phone that the scallop special should be to.